Thursday, 19 November 2026

P.Patel vs The Karnataka Real Estate Regulatory Authority & Ors. - we are of the considered view that this Tribunal, in an appropriate case, is competent to issue necessary directions to protect an allottee from adverse consequences affecting his creditworthiness and CIBIL score arising out of disputes emanating from a real estate transaction of this nature.

 REAT Karnataka (2026.11.03) in P.Patel vs The Karnataka Real Estate Regulatory Authority & Ors.  [APPEAL No.(K-REAT) 41/2025] held that; 

  • Having regard to the powers conferred upon this Tribunal under sub-sections (3) and (6) of Section 44 of the Act, we are of the considered view that this Tribunal is competent to suitably mould the relief, provided that such exercise does not introduce an altogether new cause of action or occasion prejudice to the opposite party.

  • The manner in which the third respondent is resisting the present appeal makes it abundantly clear that, taking undue advantage of the terms of the tripartite agreement, it is making every endeavour to exert pressure upon the allottee to repay the entire loan amount, notwithstanding the fact that the allottee has not derived any benefit whatsoever from the loan proceeds, which were disbursed for the benefit of the second respondent/promoter.

  • we are of the considered view that this Tribunal, in an appropriate case, is competent to issue necessary directions to protect an allottee from adverse consequences affecting his creditworthiness and CIBIL score arising out of disputes emanating from a real estate transaction of this nature.


Excerpts of the order;

The facts leading to this appeal, in brief, are as follows:

The appellant, hereinafter referred to as the ‘allottee’ for the  sake of convenience, had booked two flats bearing Nos. C- 1209 and C-1309 in the project known as ‘Aloha’, developed by the second respondent-promoter and entered into an Agreement to Sell dated 11.04.2018 for a total sale consideration of Rs.1,70,59,584/-, pursuant to which he paid an advance amount of Rs.37,00,000/-. The promoter persuaded the allottee to approach the third respondent for availing a home loan to meet the balance sale consideration. Accordingly, on 28.11.2018, the allottee, the second respondent-promoter and the third respondent entered into a Tripartite Agreement in respect of the aforesaid flats. Upon sanction of the loan, the third respondent disbursed a sum of Rs.1,13,80,672/- directly to the promoter. Thus, the allottee claims to have paid a total sum of Rs.1,50,80,672/- towards the sale consideration. As per the Agreement to Sell, the promoter had undertaken to execute and register the sale deeds in favour of the allottee and hand over possession of the flats, along with the occupancy certificate, on or before 30.09.2018. However, the promoter failed to honour the contractual obligations and continued to defer the execution and registration of the sale deeds as well as the delivery of possession. It is the specific grievance of the allottee that, despite having received a substantial portion of the sale consideration, the promoter proceeded to sell the very same flats to third parties. It is further contended that, while sanctioning the home loan, the third respondent had stipulated that only  pre-EMI interest would be payable until the registration of the flats and that the regular EMI, involving repayment of the principal amount, would commence only thereafter. Since the sale deeds have not been executed and registered till date, the third respondent has continued to levy monthly pre-EMI interest of Rs.82,561/-, without any corresponding reduction in the principal loan amount, thereby causing substantial and recurring financial loss to the allottee. Aggrieved by the aforesaid acts and omissions of the promoter, the allottee initially approached the first respondent-Authority seeking a direction to the promoter to execute and register the sale deeds in respect of the two flats in his favour. Subsequently, however, he amended the relief sought in the complaint and sought refund of the amount paid, together with interest.


# 2. Despite service of summons, respondents Nos. 2 and 3 failed to appear before the Authority and contest the complaint. Upon hearing the allottee, the Authority allowed the complaint and directed the promoter to refund a sum of Rs.63,42,993/- to the allottee, together with interest calculated at the rate of SBI MCLR plus 2% per annum from 11.04.2018 to 12.03.2025, within sixty days from the date of the order. It was further directed that the interest accruing from 13.03.2025 till the date of actual payment shall also be calculated at the same rate and paid to the allottee. In addition thereto, the promoter was directed to foreclose the outstanding loan liability of the allottee with respondent No.3 in Loan Account No.632107789, by clearing the entire outstanding amount, including all pending EMIs, interest, penalties and other charges, and thereafter obtain and furnish a No Objection Certificate to the allottee.


# 3. Being aggrieved by the impugned order dated 19.03.2025, the allottee has preferred the present appeal seeking modification of the same, contending that the Authority, while partly allowing the complaint, failed to consider the reliefs sought and properly appreciate the evidence placed on record regarding the alleged violations of the RERA Act and the Tripartite Agreement by respondents No.2 and 3. It is further contended that, despite the promoter’s failure to fulfill its contractual and statutory obligations, respondents No.2 and 3 have resorted to coercive recovery measures against the allottee and reported him as a defaulter to CIBIL, thereby adversely affecting his credit worthiness for no fault of his. According to the allottee, notwithstanding the specific directions issued by the Authority, the third respondent, instead of seeking recovery of the outstanding loan amount from the promoter, has continued to demand repayment from the allottee in respect of the very same flats which the promoter had allegedly sold to third parties. It is further contended that, despite the impugned order and repeated communications addressed by the allottee, the promoter has neither foreclosed the outstanding loan liability nor issued the requisite No Objection Certificate and has continued to demand payment, while the third respondent has failed to acknowledge or act upon the directions issued by the Authority and has continued to threaten adverse consequences to the allottee’s credit score. Hence, the allottee has sought modification of the impugned order by issuing appropriate directions to the third respondent to recover the outstanding loan amount from the promoter, desist from initiating any coercive recovery proceedings against the allottee, refrain from reporting any alleged default by the allottee in respect of Loan Account No.632107789 to CIBIL or any other credit information agency and ensure that his credit score is not adversely affected in any manner in connection with the said loan account.


# 4. In response to the notice issued by this Tribunal, respondents No.2 and 3 entered appearance through their respective counsel and respondent No.3 filed its statement  of objections contending that the allottee has no valid rounds to maintain the present appeal and has not  approached this Tribunal with clean hands. It is contended that the scope of appellate proceedings under the RERA Act is limited and cannot be misutilised to seek an altogether different or expanded relief by way of modification of the impugned order. The Authority has not recorded any adverse finding against respondent No.3 nor fastened any liability or issued any operative direction against it; on the contrary, the Authority has consciously directed only the promoter to refund the amount paid by the allottee, together with interest and other consequential reliefs. In the absence of any such direction against respondent No.3, the allottee cannot seek modification of the impugned order so as to impose fresh and independent obligations upon it. It is further contended that appellate proceedings cannot be utilised to seek reliefs which were neither sought before nor adjudicated upon by the original Authority. The provisions of the RERA Act do not contemplate adjudication of disputes between a borrower and a lending financial institution concerning repayment of loans, recovery proceedings or credit reporting, nor does this Tribunal possess jurisdiction to issue mandatory, prohibitory or coercive directions against a financial institution in matters governed by separate banking and regulatory enactments. Respondent No.3, being a financial institution, does not fall within the category of entities regulated under the RERA Act and consequently, no relief can be sought or granted against it under the said enactment. It is further contended that, instead of initiating appropriate execution proceedings against the promoter for enforcement of the impugned order, the allottee has improperly attempted to shift the burden of recovery upon respondent No.3, which is wholly impermissible. The allottee is admittedly a borrower under a valid and subsisting loan agreement and has unilaterally discontinued payment of the EMIs, thereby committing a breach of his contractual obligations, which cannot absolve him of his liability to repay the loan. There is no contractual or statutory obligation cast upon respondent No. 3 to supervise the construction, monitor the progress of the project, ensure its completion or guarantee delivery of possession of the flats, as the role and responsibilities of a ending financial institution are entirely distinct from those of a promoter or developer. The allottee cannot, under the guise of seeking modification of the impugned order, compel respondent No.3 to recover the outstanding loan amount from the promoter or restrain it from initiating lawful recovery proceedings against the borrower. On the aforesaid grounds, respondent No.3 has sought dismissal of the appeal.


# 5. We have heard the arguments advanced by the learned counsel appearing for the allottee and respondent No. 3. Despite granting sufficient opportunity, the learned counsel appearing for the promoter failed to address arguments on behalf of the promoter. Accordingly, the arguments of the learned counsel for the allottee and respondent No. 3 have been considered, and the matter is taken up for consideration on the basis of the pleadings and materials available on record.


# 6. In view of the rival contentions advanced by the parties and upon perusal of the pleadings and material available on record, the following points arise for our consideration:

  • 1. Whether the Allottee proves that the impugned order passed by the Authority warrants interference and modification by granting the ancillary reliefs sought for in the appeal?

  • 2. What order?


# 7. Our findings on the above points are as under: 

  • Point No.1 : In the Affirmative

  • Point No.2 : As per final order, for the following:


REASONS

# 8.Point No.1: Before proceeding to evaluate the point in controversy, it would be expedient to recapitulate certain undisputed facts. A perusal of the pleadings, the impugned order and the records secured from the office of the Authority would reveal that the allottee, with the intention of purchasing two flats bearing Nos.C-1209 and C-1309 for valuable consideration, entered into an Agreement to Sell with the promoter on 11.04.2018, agreeing to pay a total  sale consideration of Rs.1,70,59,584/-. Pursuant thereto, he paid a sum of Rs.37,00,000/- towards his own contribution. In respect of the remaining sale consideration, at the instance of the promoter, the allottee entered into a Tripartite Agreement with the promoter and the third respondent-financier on 28.11.2018. Pursuant to the said Tripartite Agreement, the third respondent disbursed a sum of Rs.1,13,80,672/- to the promoter, who thereby received an aggregate amount of Rs.1,50,80,672/- towards the sale consideration. As per the terms of the Agreement to Sell, the promoter was obligated to execute the sale deeds in favour of the allottee on or before 30.09.2018. However, having failed to fulfill the contractual obligation within the stipulated period, the allottee approached the Authority by filing a complaint seeking a direction to the promoter to execute the sale deeds in respect of the aforesaid flats in his favour in accordance with the terms of the Agreement to Sell. In the meanwhile, it came to the knowledge of the allottee that the promoter, with an intention to defeat his legitimate rights and  defraud him, had alienated the very same flats in favour of Mrs.Dharavath Laxmi Banjara and Sri.Algond K.Biradar under two separate sale deeds dated 08.12.2021 and 19.02.2022 respectively. In view of the subsequent developments and the impossibility of securing the originally sought relief, the allottee sought modification of the reliefs claimed in the complaint and consequently prayed for refund of the amount paid by him, together with interest thereon.


# 9. Initially, the third respondent was not arrayed as a party to the proceedings before the Authority and was subsequently impleaded as respondent No.2. However, for the reasons best known to them, neither the promoter nor the financier chose to appear before the Authority or contest the claim made by the allottee. Consequently, the Authority, placing reliance upon the assertions made by the allottee, the memo of calculation furnished by him and the principles laid down by the High Court of Delhi in Ashish Tiwari Vs. Union of India [(WP(C) 10223/2021] and by the Hon’ble Apex   Court in Union of India Vs. Rajasthan Real Estate Regulatory Authority and Others [2022 liveLaw (SC) 171] and Bikram Chatterji Vs. Union of India and Others [(2019) 19 SCC 161], proceeded to allow the complaint. Accordingly, the promoter was directed to refund the amount received towards the sale consideration from the allottee, together with interest thereon at the rate of SBI MCLR plus 2%, calculated from the respective dates of payment until the date of actual realisation. 


# 10. Even after disposal of the complaint, the allottee appears to have been confronted with further difficulties, in as much as the third respondent, allegedly taking undue advantage of the terms and conditions of the Tripartite Agreement executed between the parties, has been making coercive attempts to compel him to repay the loan amount, notwithstanding the fact that the loan proceeds were neither received nor utilised by the allottee but were disbursed directly for the benefit of the promoter. The allottee further apprehends that such coercive measures may adversely affect his creditworthiness and consequently impair his CIBIL score, thereby exposing him to further prejudice and financial hardship.


# 11. Aggrieved by the aforesaid circumstances and reiterating the difficulties being faced by him, the allottee has preferred the present appeal seeking modification of the impugned order and consequential directions to the third respondent to recover the outstanding loan amount from the promoter, who is the actual beneficiary of the loan proceeds and to desist from initiating or continuing any coercive recovery measures against him, including reporting him as a defaulter to the credit information agencies. He has further sought a direction to the third respondent not to report his loan account as a default account or take any steps that would adversely affect his creditworthiness or CIBIL score in any manner whatsoever. In support of the reliefs sought in the present appeal, the learned counsel appearing for the allottee placed reliance upon the decision of the Hon’ble Apex Court in Himanshu Singh and Others Vs. Union of India and Others [2025 LiveLaw (SC) 574]. The sum and substance of the principles laid down in the said decision may be summarised as follows:

  • “Tripartite Agreement – Subvention scheme – Home buyers alleged collusion between builders, banks, and Housing Finance Companies (HFCs) in subvention schemes, where builders promised to pay EMIs until possession but defaulted, leaving buyers liable for EMIs despite incomplete projects. Held a prima facie “unholy nexus” existed between builders, banks and HFCs, indicating a systematic failure by statutory and government authorities to perform their duties. The Court noted circumvention of the regulatory framework by banks and HFCs, with coercive actions taken against homebuyers despite incomplete units and no valid offer of possession.”


# 12. Further, the learned counsel for the allottee placed reliance upon the decision of the Hon’ble High Court of Karnataka in Mudit Saxena Vs. Union of India [ (2023) 2 KCCR 1296]. In the said decision, the High Court dealt with the issue of coercive recovery of housing loan dues by PNB Housing Finance Limited in transactions involving Tripartite Agreements executed between home buyers and developers. The Court, while examining the circumstances surrounding such transactions, restrained coercive recovery measures and issued appropriate directions to the concerned authorities to consider the claims relating to correction of the CIBIL score and issuance of a No Due Certificate. Placing reliance upon the aforesaid decision, the learned counsel contended that the third respondent/financier cannot unjustly subject the allottee to coercive recovery proceedings or adversely affect his creditworthiness when the loan proceeds were disbursed for the benefit of the promoter.


# 13. Per contra, the learned counsel appearing for the third respondent, while challenging the maintainability of the present appeal, contended that the impugned order passed by the Authority does not contain any adverse finding against the third respondent, nor does it fasten any liability upon it or issue any operative direction whatsoever against it. In the absence of any such finding, direction or liability, the allottee cannot seek modification of the impugned order by way of the present appeal. It was further contended that the reliefs now sought by the allottee were neither claimed before the Authority nor considered or adjudicated upon by it. As such, the allottee cannot be permitted to introduce entirely new reliefs or seek modification of the impugned order in respect of matters which were neither the subject matter of the original complaint nor adjudicated upon by the Authority. In support of his contentions, the learned counsel placed reliance upon the decision of the Hon’ble Apex Court in Bachhaj Nahar Vs. Nilima Mandal  [AIR 2009 SC 1103] and submitted that the relevant principles laid down therein are applicable to the facts of the present case. The relevant portion of the said decision reads as follows:

  • “… The High Court, in this case, in its obvious zeal to cut delays and hardships that may ensue by relegating the plaintiffs to one more round of litigation, has rendered a judgment which violates several fundamental rules of civil procedure. The rules breached are:

  • (i) No amount of evidence can be investigated, upon a plea which was never put forward in the pleadings. A question which did arise from the pleadings, and which was not the subject matter of an issue, cannot be decided by the court.

  • (ii) A court cannot make out a case not pleaded. The court should confine its decision to the question raised in pleadings. Nor can it grant the relief, which is not claimed, and which does not flow from the facts and 

  • (iii) A factual issue cannot be raised or considered for the first time in a second appeal”


# 14. Upon examining the law laid down by the Hon’ble Apex Court in the aforesaid decisions, it is evident that, in Bikram Chatterji Vs. Union of India and Others, the Hon’ble Apex Court held that, in the event of any conflict between the provisions of the RERA Act and the SARFAESI Act, the provisions of the RERA Act would prevail. Further, in Union of India Vs. Rajasthan Real Estate Regulatory Authority and Others, the Hon’ble Apex Court held that the RERA Authority is empowered to entertain a complaint by an aggrieved person against a bank or financial institution, in its capacity as a secured creditor, where such secured creditor takes recourse to any of the measures contemplated under Section 13(4) of the SARFAESI Act. However, the Apex Court clarified that the provisions of the RERA Act would not ordinarily govern transactions between a borrower and a bank or financial nstitution where the security interest had been created by  way of mortgage prior to the commencement of the RERA Act, unless it is established that the creation of such mortgage or the underlying transaction was fraudulent or collusive.


# 15. A copy of the Tripartite Agreement dated 28.11.2018 has been placed on record along with the Memorandum of Appeal and the date of its execution is not in dispute. Having regard to the nature of the transaction and the principles laid down by the Hon’ble Apex Court in the aforesaid decisions, it is evident that the provisions of the RERA Act are applicable to the transaction in question and to the extent of any inconsistency with the provisions of the SARFAESI Act, the former would prevail. Consequently, the Authority is vested with the jurisdiction to entertain and adjudicate upon the complaint lodged by the allottee.


# 16. Upon careful examination of the recitals and terms incorporated in the Tripartite Agreement, the respective rights, duties and obligations of the allottee, the promoter and the financier are clearly discernible. In order to appreciate the nature and extent of the contractual obligations undertaken by each of the parties and to arrive at a just and proper conclusion in the matter, it would be appropriate to extract and reproduce the relevant clauses of the said agreement. The two material clauses, which have a direct bearing on the controversy involved in the present appeal, are extracted hereunder: 

  • “HDFC will release the loan amount based on the demand raised by builder duly endorsed and authorised by borrower in writing and based on the progress of construction of the project and on the terms and conditions agreed by the all three parties in this Tripartite Agreement.”

  • “In the event of cancelation of allotment/booking/allocation of the flat by borrower or builder for whatsoever reason or in event of builder not executing-registering the sale deed in favour of borrower within the stipulated time or in the event of litigation affecting the property/flat, builder undertakes to promptly and immediately refund the entire flat sale consideration amount received by builder (from both, borrower and HDFC) to HDFC., notwithstanding whether the flat is resold or not. Borrower hereby irrevocably authorise builder to directly pay the said flat sale consideration amount to HDFC without requiring any further consent or authorization for the same.” (Underlined by us for emphasis)


# 17. Further, the observations made by the Authority in paragraph 18 of the impugned order are of considerable relevance and significance for the purpose of adjudicating the controversy involved in the present appeal. Hence, it would be appropriate to reproduce the said observations verbatim for ready reference:

  • “The 1st respondent –promoter has collected substantial amount by entering into an Agreement of Sale dated 11.04.2018. The 2nd Respondent – banker without even ascertaining the stages of construction in the said project, has disbursed the amount and the same is clearly evident from loan account statement for Loan Account No.632107789 produced by the complainant. The 1st respondent – promoter has not only miserably failed to perform its promise under the agreement to sale but has also severely violated the provisions of the Act by executing sale deeds (document No.4931/2021-22 on 08.12.2021 and 6265/2021-22 on 19.02.2022) respectively in favour of Third parties. Despite existing Agreement of Sale dated 11.04.2018 and Tripartite Agreement dated 28.11.2018 and received substantial consideration, the respondent no.1 has not intimated or cancelled regarding the same.”


# 18. In the impugned order, the Authority has categorically observed that the third respondent-financier had disbursed the loan amount without even ascertaining the stage of construction of the project. Such disbursement, without verifying the progress of construction, is also borne out by the loan account statement produced by the allottee before the Authority. 


# 19. A careful examination of the material on record would make it evident that the promoter had agreed to sell the aforesaid two flats in favour of the allottee for the total sale consideration stipulated in the Agreement to Sell and had received a sum of Rs.37,00,000/- directly from the allottee, besides procuring a further sum of Rs.1,13,80,672/- by way of a loan obtained in the name of the allottee through the Tripartite Agreement. However, despite having received substantial consideration from these sources, the promoter, allegedly with the intention of defrauding the allottee, proceeded to alienate the very same flats in favour of third parties. The said alienations are evident from the copies of the sale deeds produced by the allottee along with the memorandum of appeal. It is further significant to note that, while seeking alteration of the reliefs originally claimed in the complaint, the allottee had specifically brought these developments to the notice of the Authority. Though the third respondent-financier was subsequently impleaded as an additional respondent and the aforesaid allegations were brought to its notice, neither the third respondent nor the second respondent-promoter chose to appear before the Authority or controvert the specific averments made by the allottee. In these circumstances, it is evident that the third respondent/financier had notice, at least during the proceedings before the Authority, that the second respondent-promoter had failed to honour the terms of the Agreement to Sell and had alienated the very same flats in favour of third parties, in contravention of its contractual obligations towards the allottee.


# 20. It is pertinent to note that the Tripartite Agreement cast a specific obligation upon the third respondent-financier to obtain the prior written consent of the allottee before disbursing any loan amount in favour of the promoter. Admittedly, it is nobody’s case that the third respondent had obtained such written consent from the allottee at the time of releasing the loan proceeds to the promoter. In the absence of compliance with this express contractual stipulation, the disbursement of the loan amount without obtaining the allottee’s written consent assumes considerable significance. It is in this background that the Authority, in paragraph 18 of the impugned order, was constrained to record its observations regarding the lapses and lack of due diligence on the part of the third respondent-financier.


# 21. Notwithstanding the aforesaid serious lapses and deficiencies on its part, the third respondent-financier continues to reiterate its stand that the allottee, being the borrower under the loan transaction, is solely liable to repay the loan amount. However, such a contention, when examined in the light of the material available on record, appears to be wholly untenable and contrary to the very principles of fairness, due diligence and responsible lending that financial institutions are expected to observe while extending financial assistance in transactions involving tripartite agreements between the allottee, promoter and financier.


# 22. As rightly contended by the third respondent, the reliefs now sought by the allottee by way of modification were not specifically claimed in the original complaint before the Authority. Having regard to the settled principles of law and the law laid down by the Hon’ble Apex Court in Bachhaj Nahar Vs. Nilima Mandal, it is well settled that a party cannot ordinarily seek altogether new reliefs at the appellate stage, which were neither pleaded nor adjudicated upon by the original forum. It is true that the allottee had not specifically sought the aforesaid reliefs before the Regulatory Authority. However, the mere omission to incorporate a specific prayer in the original complaint would not, by itself, preclude this Tribunal from granting appropriate consequential or ancillary relief in an appeal preferred under Section 44 of the Act, particularly when such relief is intrinsically connected with the principal relief originally claimed and arises out of the same set of facts and circumstances. Having regard to the powers conferred upon this Tribunal under sub-sections (3) and (6) of Section 44 of the Act, we are of the considered view that this Tribunal is competent to suitably mould the relief, provided that such exercise does not introduce an altogether new cause of action or occasion prejudice to the opposite party. Accordingly, notwithstanding the absence of a specific prayer before the Authority, the request made by the allottee deserves to be examined and considered on its own merits.


# 23. In the light of the foregoing discussion, it is evident that the modifications sought by the allottee in the present appeal are merely ancillary and consequential to the principal relief originally sought before the Authority and do not constitute an altogether new or independent

cause of action. Added to this, the allottee had specifically pleaded the relevant facts and circumstances before the Authority in support of the very reliefs now sought by way of modification in the present appeal. Therefore, it cannot be said that the third respondent was taken by surprise or deprived of an opportunity to meet the case sought to be advanced by the allottee. In such circumstances, we are of the considered view that the principles laid down by the Hon’ble Apex Court in Bachhaj Nahar Vs. Nilima Mandal are distinguishable on facts and have no application to the case on hand.


# 24. The manner in which the third respondent is resisting the present appeal makes it abundantly clear that, taking undue advantage of the terms of the tripartite agreement, it is making every endeavour to exert pressure upon the allottee to repay the entire loan amount, notwithstanding the fact that the allottee has not derived any benefit whatsoever from the loan proceeds, which were disbursed for the benefit of the second respondent/promoter. In the circumstances, the appropriate remedy available to the third respondent-financier is to recover the loan amount from the second respondent-promoter, who is the actual beneficiary of the loan proceeds and, if any valid mortgage or security interest has been created in its favour in respect of the aforesaid flats, to enforce its rights against he secured property in accordance with law, rather than  subjecting the allottee to coercive recovery measures. Having regard to the principles laid down by the Hon’ble Apex Court in the aforesaid decisions and the decision of the Hon’ble High Court of Karnataka in Mudit Saxena v. Union of India, we are of the considered view that this Tribunal, in an appropriate case, is competent to issue necessary directions to protect an allottee from adverse consequences affecting his creditworthiness and CIBIL score arising out of disputes emanating from a real estate transaction of this nature. For the foregoing reasons, we are constrained to hold that the present appeal is maintainable and that the allottee is entitled to the consequential modification of the impugned order, as  prayed for. Accordingly, we answer Point No.1 in the affirmative and proceed to pass the following order: 


ORDER

  • (a) The appeal is hereby allowed;

  • (b) The impugned order dated 19.03.2026 passed by the 1st Respondent –Authority in Complaint No. CMP/211116/0008580 is hereby confirmed. However, the allottee is held entitled to the following ancillary reliefs:

  • (c) The third respondent is hereby directed to recover the outstanding loan amount, if any, from the second respondent - Promoter and to forthwith cease all coercive recovery measures against the appellant, including reporting any default in respect of the aforesaid loan account.

  • (d) The third respondent is further directed not to report, adversely affect or cause any adverse entry in the appellant’s credit information report or credit score, in any manner whatsoever, in connection with the Loan Account No.632107789.

  • (e) In view of disposal of the main appeal, pending I.As., if any, shall stand disposed of, as they do not survive for consideration;

  • (f) Registry is directed to comply with the provisions of Section 44(4) of the Act and to return the records to RERA, if any received.


There is no order as to costs.

----------------------------------------


Thursday, 12 November 2026

Ms. Richa Verma vs. M/s. Sushma Buildtech Ltd. - The Hon'ble Supreme Court in Newtech Promoters and Developers Pvt. Ltd. v. State of U.P. (Civil Appeal Nos. 6745-6749 of 2021) has also upheld that amounts payable under Section 18 of the RERD Act, 2016 with interest may be recovered as arrears of Land Revenue under Section 40(1) of the Act. In view of this Bench of Authority, the promoter has failed to give possession by the extended date of 05.06.2022, the delay is established, and the complainant is entitled to interest for every month of delay at the rate prescribed by Rule 16 of the Rules,

 RERA Punjab (2026.11.02) in Ms. Richa Verma vs. M/s. Sushma Buildtech Ltd. [GC No. 0451/2024] held that; 

  • The  Hon'ble Supreme Court in Newtech Promoters and Developers Pvt. Ltd. v. State of  U.P. (Civil Appeal Nos. 6745-6749 of 2021) has also upheld that amounts payable  under Section 18 of the RERD Act, 2016 with interest may be recovered as arrears of  Land Revenue under Section 40(1) of the Act. In view of this Bench of Authority, the  promoter has failed to give possession by the extended date of 05.06.2022, the delay is  established, and the complainant is entitled to interest for every month of delay at the  rate prescribed by Rule 16 of the Rules, 


Excerpts of the order;

# 1. The present complaint dated 24.12.2024 has been filed by Ms. Richa  Verma (hereinafter referred to as the complainant) under Section 31 of the Real Estate  (Regulation and Development) Act, 2016 (hereinafter referred to as the 'RERD Act,  2016') read with Rule 36 of the Punjab State Real Estate (Regulation and Development)  Rules, 2017 (hereinafter referred to as the Rules) against M/s Sushma Buildtech Ltd.  (respondent no. 1, hereinafter referred to as the promoter) and Kotak Mahindra Bank   Ltd. (respondent no. 2, hereinafter referred to as the bank), in respect of Residential Unit  No. K-804, 3 BHK, Tower K, in the project Sushma Crescent, situated at Kishanpura,  Sub Tehsil Zirakpur, Tehsil Derabassi, District SAS Nagar (Mohali), registered with this  Authority under registration no. PBRERA-SAS79-PR0084. 

 

# 2. The complainant alleges that she applied for the unit on 30.11.2020 and  that an Allotment Letter and a Buyer's Agreement (Agreement for Sale) were executed  on 05.12.2020 under Customer ID No. SC-0894. The carpet area of the unit is stated to  be 979.922 sq. ft. (91.037 sq. mtr.). The total price is stated to be Rs.62,66,274/-, of  which the basic sale price is Rs.55,52,300/-. For ready reference, schedule C of the  agreement for sell is attached as under:- 

2.1 She further alleges that she has paid Rs.52,85,794/- including GST as per  the construction linked plan, and that she availed a home loan of Rs.44,40,000/- from  the bank vide letter dated 22.01.2021, out of which Rs.36,00,000/- was disbursed to the  promoter. It is alleged that, as per Clause 7 of the Agreement for Sale, possession was  to be delivered on 05.12.2021; that possession has not been delivered; that the  Occupancy Certificate/Completion Certificate (OC/CC) has not been obtained; that  neither interest for delay nor compensation has been paid; and that her repeated visits  and e-mails have not yielded any result. The complainant prays that the respondents  be directed to pay interest for delayed possession under Sections 18 and 19 of the Act  as per the Rules on Rs.52,85,794/- till the date of offer of legal possession after obtaining  the OC/CC. 

 

# 3. Respondent no. 1 filed its reply dated 17.06.2025. It objects that the  complaint is liable to be dismissed for want of jurisdiction, without specifying the ground  in detail, and denies the allegations of misrepresentation and fraud. It admits that the  complainant applied on 30.11.2020, that the unit (stated to be on the 8th floor, super  area 1590 sq. ft.) was allotted vide Allotment Letter dated 05.12.2020 (Annexure R-1)  at a basic sale price of Rs.55,52,300/- excluding taxes and other charges, and that an  Agreement for Sale dated 05.12.2020 was executed, as per which possession was to  be delivered on 05.12.2021 subject to delays caused by force majeure conditions. It  contends that the delay was caused by the COVID-19 pandemic, a force majeure event,  and relies upon the advisory of the Ministry of Housing and Urban Affairs dated  13.05.2020, the circular of the Maharashtra Real Estate Regulatory Authority dated  18.05.2020, decisions of the State Consumer Disputes Redressal Commissions  (Ramesh Kumar v. Omaxe and Raman Kumar v. Omaxe), the decision of the NCDRC  in Kishor V. Patil v. Marvel Zeta Developers, and the judgments of the Hon'ble Supreme  Court in Dhanrajmal Govindram v. Shyamji Kalidas (AIR 1961 SC 1285) and Ireo Grace  Realtech Pvt. Ltd. v. Abhishek Khanna ((2021) 3 SCC 241). It further contends that the  Hon'ble Supreme Court, in Fortune Infrastructure v. Trevor D'Lima (Civil Appeal Nos.  3533-3534 of 2017, decided on 12.03.2018), held three years from the date of the  agreement to be a reasonable period, so that, with the force majeure period, the  reasonable timeframe aligns with the period within which possession was offered; that  this Authority has extended the registration of the project (Annexure R-8); and that the  roject is still being developed. 

3.1. Respondent no. 1 further pleads that, on expiry of the possession due  date, the parties executed a Settlement Agreement dated 16.09.2022 whereby the  complainant was adequately compensated for the delay, and that the complainant has  received Rs.6,48,452/- as delay possession compensation by cheques, which were  encashed. A statement of accounts is relied upon. It is contended that the complainant  has not come with clean hands, that she is a defaulter, and that a Termination Letter  dated 04.02.2021 records a default of Rs.5,34,328/- and a Demand Letter dated  10.09.2024 records a continuing default of Rs.3,10,930/-. It also relies upon Maula Bux  v. Union of India ((1969) 2 SCC 554), Kunwar Chiranjit Singh v. Har Swarup (AIR 1926  PC 1) and Godrej Projects Development Ltd. v. Anil Karlekar (decided on 03.02.2025)  for the proposition that earnest money may be forfeited and no interest is payable on  the refundable balance where the buyer defaults. It prays for dismissal of the complaint  with punitive costs. 


# 4. Respondent no. 2 filed its reply (Diary No. 4186 dated 20.06.2025). It  submits that it has been wrongly impleaded, that the dispute is between the complainant  and the promoter, that it sanctioned a home loan of Rs.44,40,000/- vide Sanction Letter  dated 22.01.2021, of which Rs.36,00,000/- was disbursed directly to the promoter on  the instructions of the complainant and on the basis of the promoter's certificates of   construction progress, that it is neither a promoter nor an allottee within the meaning of  Sections 2(zk) and 2(d) of the Act, that it is not a signatory to the Agreement for Sale,  and that no relief is sought against it. It prays that the complaint be rejected qua  respondent no. 2. 


# 5. The complainant filed a rejoinder (served on 23.09.2025). It states that the  complaint is maintainable as the project is situated in Punjab and is registered with this  Authority; that the complainant is an allottee within Section 2(d) of the Act; that the  circular of this Authority dated 28.10.2020 extends force majeure relief to completion  dates and statutory compliances falling between 15.03.2020 and 15.09.2020, whereas  the Agreement for Sale was executed on 05.12.2020, so that the promoter cannot take  the plea of COVID-19; that Clause 9.2 of the model agreement entitles the allottee to  interest at the prescribed rate for every month of delay; that the promoter has not  obtained the OC/CC; that the complainant has paid Rs.52,85,794/-, stated to be  approximately 95% of the total sale price, and the balance is payable at the time of offer  of possession; and that the allegation of default is denied. 


# 6. The violations and contraventions contained in the complaint were given  to the representative of the respondents to which they denied and did not plead guilty  The complaint was proceeded for further inquiry. 


# 7. That representatives for parties addressed arguments on the basis of their  submissions made in their respective pleadings as summarised above. I have duly  considered the documents filed and written & oral submissions of the parties i.e.,  complainant and respondents. 


# 8. It is further pertinent to note that during the pendency of the present  proceedings, the learned counsel appearing on behalf of respondent no. 1 withdrew his power of attorney on 23.06.2026. Thereafter, no one appeared on behalf of respondent  no. 1 before this Bench. However, prior thereto, respondent no. 1 was duly represented  through its learned counsel, Sh. Sanjeev Sharma, and had also filed its reply to the  complaint. It is observed that respondent no. 1 was afforded ample and repeated opportunities to appear, participate in the proceedings and advance submissions in  support of its defence. However, despite the opportunities so afforded, none appeared  on its behalf after withdrawal of the power of attorney. No sufficient cause for its  continued non-appearance was brought to the notice of this Bench of Authority, nor was  any request seeking further opportunity to represent its case received. This Bench of  Authority is, therefore, satisfied that respondent no. 1 has been afforded reasonable and  sufficient opportunities to participate in the proceedings, but it has failed to avail the  same. In these circumstances, no useful purpose would be served by granting further  adjournments. Accordingly, the proceedings are being taken forward in the absence of  respondent no. 1, and the present complaint is being adjudicated on the basis of the  pleadings, replies, documents and other material available on record. It is clarified that  the non-appearance of respondent no. 1 shall not, by itself, be construed as an  admission of the allegations levelled by the complainant, and the matter is being decided  on its own merits and in accordance with law. 


# 9. During the arguments, Sh. Mohd. Sartaj Khan, learned counsel for the  complainant, submitted that the amount of Rs.6,48,452/- received by the complainant  may be deducted out of the interest receivable by her. It was recorded that the OC/CC  has not been obtained by the respondent till date. It was further recorded that six months'  time on account of COVID-19 is to be given, as the due date of possession falls within.  the COVID-19 period extension granted, and that the same was not objected to by the  learned counsel for the complainant. It was stated that the complainant had paid  Rs.52,85,794/- up to 05.12.2021 and that a further amount of Rs.2,91,495/- was paid by  her on 06.09.2023. Ms. Simran Paul, learned counsel for respondent no. 2, submitted  that no payment is receivable from the promoter by the bank, that the loan advanced to  the complainant has been fully received by the bank, that no dues are pending, and that  respondent no. 2 may be dropped from the proceedings. The record placed before this  Bench of Authority does not reflect any oral submission on behalf of respondent no. 1  other than reliance on its reply and Annexures R-1 to R-8. 


# 10. The following facts are admitted or not disputed. The complainant applied  for the unit on 30.11.2020. The Allotment Letter and the Agreement for Sale were  executed on 05.12.2020. The basic sale price is Rs.55,52,300/-. The date of possession  fixed by the Agreement for Sale is 05.12.2021, as pleaded by the complainant an recorded by the promoter in its reply, which adds that it is subject to force majeure. The  project is registered with this Authority and is stated by the promoter to be still under  development. The bank disbursed Rs.36,00,000/- to the promoter. The complainant  received Rs.6,48,452/- from the promoter as delay compensation under the Settlement  Agreement dated 16.09.2022. The OC/CC has not been obtained, as stated at the  hearing, and the promoter has not placed on record any OC/CC or any letter offering  possession. 


# 11. This Bench of Authority finds that the complainant is an allottee within the  meaning of Section 2(d) of the RERD Act, 2016. The Allotment Letter and Agreement  for Sale dated 05.12.2020 were executed between the parties, the promoter admits the  allotment, and it has accepted payments, raised demands and maintains a statement of  account in the name of the complainant. The project is registered with this Authority.  The complainant alleges failure to give possession by the agreed date and failure to  obtain the OC/CC, which are matters relating to Sections 11, 17, 18 and 19 of the RERD Act, 2016. This Authority has jurisdiction to entertain the complaint under Sections 31,  34(f) and 37 of the RERD Act, 2016. The promoter's general objection to maintainability  has not been supported by any particulars, and is rejected. 


# 12. As regards respondent no. 2, no relief is claimed against it in the  complaint, and the statement made on its behalf at the hearing that the loan has been  fully received and that no dues are pending has not been shown to be disputed. In the  view of this Bench of Authority, no cause of action is established against respondent no.  2, and it is liable to be dropped from the array of respondents. This finding does not  adjudicate any right or liability between the complainant and the bank under the loan  documents, which are not before this Bench of Authority for adjudication.  


# 13. The date of possession fixed by the "Agreement for Sale" is 05.12.2021.  The promoter pleads force majeure on account of COVID-19. The record reveals that  the Agreement for Sale was executed on 05.12.2020, whereas the circular of this  Authority dated 28.10.2020 (Annexure C-1) extends the validity of registration, and the  time for statutory compliances, in respect of dates falling on or after 15.03.2020 or  between 15.03.2020 and 15.09.2020. However, it was recorded at the hearing that six  months' time on account of COVID-19 is to be given and that the same is not objected  to by the learned counsel for the complainant. In view of this position, and in the absence  of any objection at the time of arguments, a period of six months on account of COVID- 19 is granted to the respondent, so that the date of possession stands extended to  05.06.2022. 

 

# 14. The promoter also contends, relying on Fortune Infrastructure v. Trevor  D'Lima, that three years from the date of the agreement is a reasonable period, and that  possession was offered within that period. This contention is not accepted. In the  present case the Agreement for Sale itself fixes a specific date of possession, which the  promoter admits in its reply, and the promoter has not shown that the judgment permits  an assumed reasonable period to displace a date agreed in writing. The statement in  paragraph 14 of the reply that possession was offered within the acceptable period is  not supported by any offer letter, none is listed among Annexures R-1 to R-8, and the  same reply states in paragraph 17 that the promoter is still developing the project and  has obtained an extension. The extension of the registration granted by this Authority  (Annexure R-8) operates as between the promoter and the Authority for regulatory  purposes, and it is not shown that it modifies the date of possession agreed with the  allottee. It is therefore established from the material on record that possession was not  offered by 05.06.2022, and has not been offered till date. 


# 15. The promoter alleges default by the complainant and relies on the  Termination Letter dated 04.02.2021 and the Demand Letter dated 10.09.2024. The  complainant denies any default and states that she paid as per the payment schedule  and that the balance is payable at the time of offer of possession. The record placed  before this bench of Authority does not establish that the allotment stands cancelled,  nor does the promoter plead cancellation or claim forfeiture of any amount or seek any  refund. On the contrary, the record reveals that, after the Termination Letter dated  04.02.2021, the promoter itself entered into the Settlement Agreement dated  16.09.2022, paid delay compensation to the complainant, and issued the Demand Letter  dated 10.09.2024, and it has been stated at the hearing that a payment of Rs.2,91,495/-  was made on 06.09.2023. This conduct of the promoter is inconsistent with the case  that the allotment stood terminated. The promoter's own obligation to deliver possession  by the agreed date and to complete the project, is independent of the alleged arrears.  The alleged amounts of default are not established by any reconciled account on the  record. If any payment by the complainant was delayed, the promoter's remedy lies in  interest on the delayed payment under Section 19(7) of the Act read with Rule 16 of the  Rules, which can be claimed only if specific notice of the delay and of the amount of  interest was given to the complainant, and which is left to be adjusted in the manner  directed below. 

 

# 16. The Settlement Agreement dated 16.09.2022 (Annexure R-3) is on record.  The promoter pleads that the complainant was adequately compensated thereby and is  not entitled to any further amount, but the material on record does not establish that the  agreement contains an express waiver by the complainant of her statutory right to  interest under the proviso to Section 18(1) of the RERD Act, 2016. The complainant's  allegation of fraud in respect of that agreement is not supported by particulars or  evidence on the record, and was not pressed at the hearing, where her learned counsel  himself submitted that Rs.6,48,452/- may be deducted from the interest receivable. It is  not disputed that Rs.6,48,452/- was received by the complainant as delay  compensation. It is therefore unnecessary to decide the plea of fraud. The amount of  Rs.6,48,452/- is to be given credit to the promoter by deducting it from the interest  payable, as submitted on behalf of the complainant, and the question whether the  Settlement Agreement bars any further interest is not required to be decided beyond  this adjustment, which the complainant herself accepts. 


# 17. The complainant does not seek to withdraw from the project, and seeks  possession, the OC/CC and interest. Her entitlement is therefore governed by the  proviso to Section 18(1) of the RERD Act, 2016, under which an allottee who does not  intend to withdraw from the project shall be paid by the promoter interest for every month  of delay, till the handing over of the possession, at such rate as may be prescribed. The  Hon'ble Supreme Court in Newtech Promoters and Developers Pvt. Ltd. v. State of  U.P. (Civil Appeal Nos. 6745-6749 of 2021) has also upheld that amounts payable  under Section 18 of the RERD Act, 2016 with interest may be recovered as arrears of  Land Revenue under Section 40(1) of the Act. In view of this Bench of Authority, the  promoter has failed to give possession by the extended date of 05.06.2022, the delay is  established, and the complainant is entitled to interest for every month of delay at the  rate prescribed by Rule 16 of the Rules, namely the State Bank of India's highest  marginal cost of lending rate plus two percent. The State Bank of India's highest  marginal cost of lending rate applicable on 15.10.2026 is taken as 8.95 percent, so that  the rate of interest is 10.95 percent per annum. Interest is to be calculated from the  month following the extended due date, namely 01.07.2022, on the amount of  Rs.52,85,794/-, and from 01.10.2023 on the amount of Rs.2,91,495/- paid on  06.09.2023, in accordance with the practice that interest on an amount runs from the  month following the month in which it was paid or, if later, from the month following the  due date, till the valid offer of possession after obtaining the OC/CC.  


# 18.The interest for the delayed period is accordingly calculated up to  31.10.2026, the period for payment of interest being considered from the month  following the extended due date or the date of payment, as the case may be. Therefore,  the calculation of delayed interest is calculated as follows:- 

  • Total interest Rs.26,06,536/- 

  • Less: delay compensation already received under Settlement  (-) Rs.6,48,452/- 

  • Net interest payable up to 31.10.2026 Rs.19,58,084/- 

 

# 19.  The interest per month at 10.95 percent per annum is Rs.48,233/- on  Rs.52,85,794/- and Rs.2,660/- on Rs.2,91,495/-, which for 52 months from 01.07.2022  and 37 months from 01.10.2023 respectively, up to 31.10.2026, amounts to  Rs.25,08, 116/- and Rs.98,420/-, a total of Rs.26,06,536/-. After deducting Rs.6,48,452/-  already received by the complainant, the net interest payable up to 31.10.2026 is  Rs. 19,58,084/-. From 01.11.2026, interest continues to accrue at Rs.50,893/- per month  (Rs.48,233/- plus Rs.2,660/-) till the date of a valid offer of possession after obtaining  the OC/CC. 

 

# 20. For the reasons recorded above, the complaint is Partly Allowed. The  prayer for interest for delayed possession is allowed to the extent determined above.  The prayer for directions to obtain the OC/CC, offer possession and execute the  conveyance deed is allowed in the terms below. The prayer for litigation costs is  declined. The complaint against respondent no. 2 is not maintainable and is dismissed.  Accordingly, the following directions are issued. 


# 21. Respondent no. 1 shall pay to the complainant interest at the rate of 10.95  percent per annum on Rs.52,85,794/- from 01.07.2022 and on Rs.2,91,495/- from  01.10.2023, till the date of a valid offer of possession after obtaining the OC/CC. The  net amount of interest up to 31.10.2026, after deducting Rs.6,48,452/- already paid, is  Rs.19,58,084/-, which respondent no. 1 shall pay to the complainant within 90 days from  the date of receipt of this order. From 01.11.2026 respondent no. 1 shall further pay  interest at Rs.50,893/- per month till the date of a valid offer of possession after obtaining  the OC/CC on an amount of Rs.55,77,289/-. 


# 22. Respondent no. 1 shall obtain the Occupancy Certificate/Completion  Certificate from the competent authority and, in exercise of the powers under Section  37 of the RERD Act, 2016, shall issue a letter of offer of possession to the complainant  within seven days of receipt of the OC/CC, or simultaneously with the offer to any other  allottee of the project. The complainant shall take possession within the period provided  in Section 19(10) of the RERD Act, 2016 after the valid offer. 


# 23. Any amount payable by the complainant to the promoter under the  Agreement for Sale at the time of offer of possession shall be adjusted against the  amount awarded under this order together with the further monthly interest, and only the  net balance shall be payable by the party concerned. The promoter shall demand its  dues from the complainant only after paying or adjusting the amount determined in this  order. Any claim of the promoter for interest on delayed payments shall be admissible  only if specific notice of the delay and of the amount of interest was given to the  complainant earlier, and shall be calculated in accordance with Section 19(7) of the Act  and Rule 16 of the Rules. Till the entire awarded amount and accrued interest are paid  or adjusted, the complainant shall not be liable to pay maintenance charges to the  promoter, except where maintenance has been handed over to a Resident Welfare  Association or a third-party agency, against which no such adjustment shall be claimed.  In case of non-compliance, the net amount of Rs.19,58,084/- up to  31.10.2026 and the further interest at Rs.50,893/- per month from 01.11.2026 shall be  recoverable as arrears of land revenue under Section 40(1) of the Act read with the  Punjab Land Revenue Act, 1887, and are held to be land revenue for that purpose. The  Secretary of this Authority shall issue a Debt Recovery Certificate after 90 days from the  date of this order for those amounts, and send it to the jurisdictional Deputy  Commissioner, with a copy to both parties by e-mail and speed post. The amount  determined as interest upon the delayed period is held "Land Revenue" under the  provisions of Section 40(1) of the RERD Act, 2016. The said amounts are to be  collected as Land Revenue by the Competent Authorities as provided/authorized  in the Punjab Land Revenue Act, 1887 read with section 40(1) of the Real Estate  (Regulation and Development) Act, 2016. Any payment to any of the complainants  will be considered as payment towards all the complainants and in satisfaction of the  decree amount mentioned in this order. The recovery certificate to be issued should  specifically mention this direction for the Land Revenue Recovery Authorities. It is  directed at the cost of repetition that primarily the promoter i.e. M/s. Sushma  Buildtech Ltd. (Respondent no. 1) is responsible for payment of money  determined in this order. The proceedings u/s. 40(1) of the RERD Act, 2016 for  issue of recovery certificate are additional and a parallel legal remedy to recover  the dues determined under this order to be collected by the prescribed authority  under Punjab Land Revenue Act, 1874.  


# 25. However, at the cost of repetition it is ordered in addition to the discussion  and direction at various places in the order as follows:-  

  • i. Respondent no. 1, M/s Sushma Buildtech Ltd., shall pay the  complainant interest at the rate of 10.95% per annum on the amounts  deposited, as determined in this order, till the date of valid offer of  possession after obtaining the OC/CC. 

  • ii. The net interest amount of Rs.19,58,084/- calculated up to  31.10.2026, after adjustment of Rs.6,48,452/- already paid as delay  compensation, shall be paid within 90 days from the date of receipt of this order.  

  • iii. Further interest of Rs.50,893/- per month shall accrue with effect  from 01.11.2026 till the date of valid offer of possession after obtaining the  OC/CC. 

  • iv. Respondent no. 1 shall obtain the requisite Occupancy Certificate/Completion Certificate from the competent authority and issue  an offer of possession to the complainant within seven days thereof or  simultaneously with the offer made to other allottees of the project. 

  • V. The complainant shall take possession within the period prescribed  under Section 19(10) of the Act after receipt of a valid offer of possession.  

  • vi. Any amount payable by the complainant under the Agreement for  Sale shall be adjusted against the amount awarded under this order, along with accrued interest, and only the net balance, if any, shall be payable by  the concerned party. The promoter shall raise its demand only after  payment or adjustment of the amount awarded.  

  • vii. Any claim of the promoter towards interest on delayed payments  shall be considered only upon proof of prior specific notice to the  complainant and shall be calculated in accordance with Section 19(7) of  the Act read with Rule 16 of the Rules. 

  • viii. The complainant shall not be liable to pay maintenance charges to the promoter till the awarded amount along with accrued interest is paid or  adjusted, except where maintenance has been handed over to the Resident Welfare Association or a third-party agency. 

  • ix. In the event of non-compliance, the amount due under this order,  along with further accrued interest, shall be recoverable as arrears of land revenue under Section 40(1) of the RERD Act, 2016, read with the  applicable provisions of the Punjab Land Revenue Act, 1887. The  Secretary of this Authority shall issue the requisite Debt Recovery Certificate after expiry of 90 days from the date of this order. 

  • x. The complaint against respondent no. 2, Kotak Mahindra Bank Ltd.,  stands dismissed, as no cause of action or relief has been established  against it. 

 

# 26. The Secretary of this Authority is hereby directed to issue a "Debt  Recovery Certificate" after 90 days of receipt of this order, for the balance amount  of interest on delayed possession remaining after the adjustment directed above.  He will send the Debt Recovery Certificate to the jurisdictional Deputy  Commissioner of the District being Competent/ jurisdictional Authority as  mentioned in the Punjab Land Revenue Act, 1887 after 90 days of the issuance of  this order to be recovered as arrears of "Land Revenue". The complainant & the  respondent are directed to inform the Secretary of this Authority regarding any payment  received or paid respectively so as to take the same in to account before sending  "Recovery Certificate" to the Competent Authority for recovery. Further, Ms. Richa  Verma is held to be Decree Holder and the Respondent i.e. M/s. Sushma Buildtech  Ltd. as judgment debtor for the purposes of recovery under this order. 


# 27. A copy of this order be supplied to both the parties under Rules and file be  consigned to record room. 

---------------------------------------------------